Quantum Gravity and Random Geometry

Amphithéâtre Hermite (Institut Henri Poincaré)

Amphithéâtre Hermite

Institut Henri Poincaré

11 rue Pierre et Marie Curie 75005 Paris

This workshop is part of the thematic six-weeks program "Quantum gravity, random geometry and holography" held at Institut Henri Poincaré, Paris (program main page)

The workshop will be devoted to quantum gravity approaches in two, three, and four dimensions, with an emphasis on the random geometry point of view.
In the tradition of the conference series ``Quantum Gravity in Paris'', we aim at bringing together researchers working on various approaches to quantum gravity, fostering an open minded exchange of ideas and techniques, to be continued in the weeks after the workshop.


Video recordings of the talks are available on carmin.tv.

Invited speakers:

Jan Ambjorn (NBI, Denmark)
Laurent Baulieu (LPTHE, Sorbonne Univ., France)
Valentin Bonzom (Univ. Sorbonne Paris Nord, France)
Gaetan Borot (Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Germany)
Timothy Budd (IMAPP, The Netherlands)
Sylvain Carrozza (IMB, Dijon, France)
François David (CEA Saclay, France)
Bianca Dittrich (Perimeter Institute, Canada)
Maïté Dupuis (Perimeter Institute, Canada)
Renata Ferrero (Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Germany)
Florian Girelli (U. Waterloo, Canada)
Thomas Krajewski (CPT, Aix-Marseille Univ., France)
Riccardo Martini (INFN, Pisa, Italy)
Tim Morris (Univ. Southampton, UK)
Daniele Oriti (LMU, Munich, Germany)
Antonio Duarte Pereira (Fluminense Federal University, Brazil)
Andreas Pithis (LMU, Munich, Germany)
Marcus Reitz (Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Poland)
Naoki Sasakura (Kyoto Univ., Japan)
Simone Speziale (CPT, Marseille, France)
Sumati Surya (Raman Research Institute, India)
Johannes Thürigen (Univ. Münster, Germany)
Reiko Toriumi (OIST, Japan)
Raimar Wulkenhaar (Univ. Münster, Germany)


John Barrett (University of Nottingham)
Dario Benedetti (Ecole Polytechnique)
Joseph Ben Geloun (Université Sorbonne Paris Nord)
Renate Loll (Radboud University Nijmegen)

Group photos:


  • Abel Nguelemo Kenfack
  • Adrian Tanasa
  • Alicia Castro
  • Andreas Pithis
  • Arad Nasiri
  • Ariane Carrance
  • Bart Zonneveld
  • Bram Petri
  • Carlos I. Perez-Sanchez
  • Christina Thompson-Acquah
  • Dana Ioan
  • Daniele Oriti
  • Dario Benedetti
  • Dejan Stojkovic
  • Dániel Németh
  • Fabien Vignes-Tourneret
  • Florence Da silva
  • Florian Girelli
  • Fortuné Massamba
  • Francois David
  • Frank Ferrari
  • Fredrik Viklund
  • Gaetan Borot
  • Giulia Mazzola
  • Gloria Odak
  • Goffredo Chirco
  • Hristu Culetu
  • Jan Ambjorn
  • Jeanne Scott
  • Jinzhao Wang
  • Johannes Thürigen
  • John Barrett
  • Joseph Bengeloun
  • Justin Kulp
  • Kaustav Dipta Goswami
  • laurent baulieu
  • Laurent Menard
  • Luca Lionni
  • Luigi Tedesco
  • Mahougnon Justin Landalidji
  • Marcus Reitz
  • Maria Rita Casali
  • Masoud Khalkhali
  • Maximilian Becker
  • Maïté Dupuis
  • Naoki Sasakura
  • Nathan Hayford
  • Paola Cristofori
  • Petr Horava
  • Praveen Kumar Dhankar
  • Reiko Toriumi
  • Renata Ferrero
  • Riccardo Martini
  • Roukaya Dekhil
  • Sagar Kumar Maity
  • Sara Kanzi
  • Seth Asante
  • Simran Arora
  • Sristy Agrawal
  • Sylvain Carrozza
  • Sylvie Lhermitte
  • Thomas MULLER
  • Thordur Jonsson
  • Tim Morris
  • Timothy Budd
  • Victor Nador
  • Woudi Rodrigue Woudi
  • Yilin Wang
  • +13
    • 9:05 AM 9:15 AM
      Welcome and opening remarks 10m
    • 9:15 AM 9:30 AM
      Presentation of the IHP by the deputy director 15m
      Speaker: Dominique Mouhanna (IHP)
    • 9:30 AM 10:20 AM
      The universe as a quantum fluid: quantum gravity, hydrodynamics and cosmology 50m

      The hydrodynamics of quantum fluids can be mapped to relativistic cosmological dynamics, and both share the same conformal symmetries, which can be unravelled via geometric methods in superspace. This suggests a more general correspondence between hydrodynamics and cosmology, and a picture of the universe as a quantum gravity condensate. This picture is in fact realized also in some quantum gravity formalisms, like group field theory and lattice gravity, in which an emergent cosmological dynamics can be extracted from the quantum dynamics of fundamental quantum simplices in a condensate phase.
      A key ingredient is the relational understanding of space and time, which makes superspace the natural arena for gravitational dynamics, as opposed to the "spacetime" manifold. These results suggest an exciting dialogue between quantum gravity, the theory of quantum fluids and cosmology, as well as a new direction for analogue gravity simulations in the lab.

      Speaker: Daniele Oriti (Arnold Sommerfeld Center for Theoretical Physics, LMU, Munich)
    • 10:20 AM 10:50 AM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 10:50 AM 11:40 AM
      Extended corner symmetry algebra and the Wald-Zoupas prescription 50m

      Boundaries and corners of gravitational subsystems allow the
      construction of non-trivial Noether charges generating
      infinite-dimensional symmetries, which have been advocated as a new
      promising tool to understand quantum gravity. In this talk I will
      focus on classical properties of these symmetries, with the goals of
      explaining how they appear, how they provide a description of
      non-local observables, and how physical prescriptions are required in
      order to remove ambiguities in their construction.

      Speaker: Simone Speziale (CNRS, CPT Marseille)
    • 11:40 AM 12:30 PM
      3d Quantum Gravity and Quantum Groups 50m

      I will give a quick overview of the q-deformed Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) model which describes 3-dimensional quantum gravity with a cosmological constant. The model is characterized in terms of quantum group structures and the quantum Hamiltonian constraints define the Wheeler-DeWitt equations in this framework and generate the Turaev-Viro model (with real q, q being the deformation parameter). I will show, using the spinorial approach, how to construct a complete set of observables and how the notion of parallel transport can be encoded in terms of a quantum R-matrix.

      Speaker: Maïté Dupuis
    • 12:30 PM 2:30 PM
      Lunch break 2h
    • 2:30 PM 3:20 PM
      Random matrices and magnetic amplitude for discretized strings 50m

      Magnetic amplitudes for strings in a background 3-form H involve a 2-form potential B integrated on surfaces of arbitrary topology. We propose a random matrix model whose topological expansion lead to a discretized version of these amplitudes, in the case of a propagation on an finite space X quotiented by a finite group G. Besides the fluxes induced by B, they also involve topological defects on the surface, weighted by additional fields that are constructed using the group cohomology of G.

      Speaker: Thomas Krajewski (Centre de Physique Théorique, Aix-Marseille Université)
    • 3:20 PM 3:50 PM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 3:50 PM 4:20 PM
      Towards the phase structure of first order Lorentzian Palatini gravity via Group field theory 30m

      The Barrett-Crane (BC) spin foam and GFT model is a state-sum model which provides a tentative quantization of first order Lorentzian Palatini gravity written as a constrained BF-theory. Its completion in terms of spacelike, timelike and lightlike components has only recently been accomplished. It is conjectured that this model gives rise to continuum spacetime with General Relativity as an effective description for the dynamics at criticality via phase transition.
      In this talk, we discuss how phase transitions in this model can be studied using Landau-Ginzburg mean-field theory. In a first step, we demonstrate this by restricting the building blocks of the complete model such that the Feynman diagrams are dual to spacelike triangulations. This setting lays the groundwork to study the critical behavior when arbitrary Lorentzian building blocks are incorporated and also paves the way for the analysis of the phase structure of the complete model via functional renormalization group techniques in future research. This work is based on arXiv:2112.00091, arXiv:2206.15442, arXiv:2209.04297 and arXiv:2211.12768.

      Speaker: Andreas Pithis (Universität München (LMU, ASC, MCQST))
    • 4:20 PM 4:50 PM
      Flowing from Tensor Field Theory to Tensor Models 30m

      Fields with tensor degrees of freedom provide non-trivial but tractable QFT examples. Their perturbative expansion might (but does not need to) be interpreted as generating random geometries and they can be extended to models of quantum gravity in the spirit of tensorial group field theory. In the later case the tensor degrees of freedom propagate and contribute to the scale of the theory, in contrast to tensor model QFTs. In this talk we discuss how these two kind of theories can be dynamically connected via a renormalization group flow, thereby opening up the possibility that SYK-related tensor theories and random geometry models of quantum gravity are just different regimes of one and the same theory.

      Speaker: Johannes Thürigen (WWU Münster)
    • 9:30 AM 10:20 AM
      Asymptotically Safe Unimodular Quantum Gravity: a Status Report 50m

      Unimodular Gravity is an alternative description of the gravitational dynamics that is equivalent to General Relativity within the classical realm. Since it is based on a different symmetry group, volume-preserving diffeomorphisms, it could be expected that Unimodular Gravity displays very different quantum properties with respect to the quantization of a full diffeomorphism-invariant theory. I will discuss how this comparison fits in the asymptotic safety program for quantum gravity as well as point out the recent progress in this direction. Moreover, I will raise some potential conceptual consequences of such a discussion in a broader quantum-gravity perspective.

      Speaker: Antônio Duarte Pereira (Radboud University & Fluminense Federal University)
    • 10:20 AM 10:50 AM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 10:50 AM 11:40 AM
      Provable properties of asymptotic safety in f(R) approximation 50m

      We study an $f(R)$ approximation to asymptotic safety, using a family of cutoffs, kept general to test for universality. Matching solutions on the four-dimensional sphere and hyperboloid, we prove properties of any such global fixed point solution and its eigenoperators. For this family of cutoffs, the scaling dimension at large $n$ of the $n^\text{th}$ eigenoperator, is $\lambda_n\propto b\, n\ln n$. The coefficient $b$ is non-universal, a consequence of the single-metric approximation. For right-sign conformal mode cutoff, the fixed points form at most a discrete set. The eigenoperator spectrum is quantised. They are square integrable under the Sturm-Liouville weight. For wrong sign cutoff, as required if starting from the Einstein-Hilbert action, the fixed points form a continuum, and so do the eigenoperators unless we impose square-integrability. If we do this, we get a discrete tower of operators, infinitely many of which are relevant. These are $f(R)$ analogues of novel operators in the conformal sector which were used recently to furnish an alternative quantisation of gravity.

      Speaker: Tim Morris (University of Southampton)
    • 11:40 AM 12:30 PM
      Entropy versus the Action in Causal Set Theory 50m

      The quantum partition function of causal set quantum gravity is a phase weighted
      sum over all locally finite posets or causal sets. As the size n of the causal sets grows, however,
      the overwhelmingly dominant entropic contribution comes from a class of causal sets that look nothing
      like continuum spacetime. A long standing question has been whether this entropy can be overcome
      in the large n, classical limit by the discrete Einstein-Hilbert Action, to give spacetime-like
      causal sets a fighting chance. I will discuss recent progress on this as well as some of the open
      strands of questions that still remain.

      Speaker: Sumati Surya (Raman Research Institute)
    • 12:30 PM 2:30 PM
      Lunch break 2h
    • 2:30 PM 3:20 PM
      A universal mechanism for the emergence of gravitons from effective spin foams and lattice gravity 50m

      Spin foams are discretized path integrals for quantum gravity based on a rigorous definition of quantum geometry. This does however lead to very complicated amplitudes, making e.g. the extraction of a continuum limit difficult. Thus, a long-standing open question was whether spin foams do describe gravity in their semi-classical and continuum limit.
      The situation has changed with the recent introduction of effective spin foams, which on the one hand are much more amenable to numerical simulations, but also offer a much more transparent encoding of the dynamics.
      This has allowed first results on the perturbative continuum limit, which reveal that effective spin foams do lead to gravitons. I will explain an underlying mechanism applicable to a large class of models and choices of underlying lattices.
      Furthermore, one can derive a lowest order correction to the Einstein Hilbert action, given by a Weyl squared terms. These results can be confirmed by an independent construction, that works entirely in the continuum, and is based on a modification of the Plebanski formulation of Gravity.

      Speaker: Bianca Dittrich (Perimeter Institute)
    • 3:20 PM 3:50 PM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 3:50 PM 4:20 PM
      Renormalization of composite operators in $2+\varepsilon$ quantum gravity 30m

      We consider higher derivative composite operators in the $\varepsilon$-expansion of 2d quantum gravity and renormalize them at one-loop. We extract the flow of the essential couplings and study their analytic continuation in the background dimensions to compare with Stelle gravity in d=4.

      Speaker: Riccardo Martini (INFN - Sezione di Pisa)
    • 4:20 PM 4:50 PM
      Background-independent field quantization: N-cutoffs regularization and N-geometries 30m

      We apply a novel background-independent and scale-free quantization scheme on (non-)compact maximally symmetric spacetimes. The "N-cutoffs" is a UV regularization procedure on the spectrum of the fields’ fluctuation modes implemented on the quantum number. We apply this regularization to scalar and metric fluctuations: both are found to reduce the curvature of the "N-geometries" leading to vanishing values in the limit of removing the cutoff. We argue then how the curvature singularity related to the "cosmological constant problem" is an artifact resulting from a rigid-background-dependent computation.

      Speaker: Renata Ferrero (Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz)
    • 6:30 PM 9:00 PM
      Cocktail dinner 2h 30m
    • 9:30 AM 10:20 AM
      Blobbed topological recursion of the $\lambda\phi^4$ matrix model 50m

      We consider an $N\times N$ Hermitian matrix model with measure $d\mu_{E,\lambda}(\Phi)=\frac{1}{Z} \exp(-\frac{\lambda N}{4} \mathrm{tr}(\Phi^4)) d\mu_{E,0}(\Phi)$ where $d\mu_{E,0}$ is the Gau\ss{}ian measure with covariance $\langle \Phi_{kl}\Phi_{mn}\rangle =\frac{\delta_{kn}\delta_{lm}}{N(E_k+E_l)}$ for given $E_1,...,E_N>0$. We explain how this setting gives rise to two ramified coverings $x,y$ of the Riemann sphere strongly tied by $y(z)=-x(-z)$ and a family $\omega_{g,n}$ of meromorphic differentials. We provide strong evidence that the $\omega_{g,n}$ obey blobbed topological recursion due to Borot and Shadrin. A key step is to extract from the matrix model a system of six meromorphic functions which satisfy interwoven Dyson-Schwinger equations. Two of these functions are symmetric in the preimages of $x$ and can be determined from their consistency relations. Their expansion at $\infty$ gives global linear and quadratic loop equations for the $\omega_{g,n}$. These global equations provide the $\omega_{g,n}$ not only in the vicinity of the ramification points of $x$ but also in the vicinity of all other poles located at opposite diagonals $z_i+z_j=0$ and at $z_i=0$.

      Speaker: Raimar Wulkenhaar (University of Münster)
    • 10:20 AM 10:50 AM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 10:50 AM 11:40 AM
      Topological recursion for weighted Hurwitz numbers 50m

      Combinatorial maps are a well-known discrete approach to 2-dimensional quantum gravity. Planar maps satisfy multiple universal properties at large scale, which guarantee the universality of the continuum limit. But more universal structures can be observed in the all-genera structures of maps, e.g. they satisfy the KP integrable hierarchy and the topological recursion. Double weighted Hurwitz numbers are a generalization of maps, for which it was natural to ask whether the same universal properties hold true. In particular, the KP hierarchy being known to be satisfied, is it possible to prove the topological recursion? I will explain in details what the weighted Hurwitz numbers are and derive their generating series in the Schur basis. I will finally explain how we proved the topological recursion for them recently. While another group proved the same result simultaneously, it is remarkable that our methods are completely different. I will explain the originality of our approach. It is based on a work with G. Chapuy, S. Charbonnier and E. Garcia-Failde.

      Speaker: Valentin Bonzom (LIPN - Institut Galilée - Université Paris 13)
    • 11:40 AM 12:30 PM
      Topological recursion in 2d quantum gravity 50m

      I will explain the idea of topological recursion, its implementation for the enumeration of maps (and of large maps), and mention other applications to compute integrals over the moduli space of Riemann surfaces M_{g,n}. I will introduce the idea of geometric recursion which in certain cases allows for a fully geometric proof that topological recursion solves such problems.

      Speaker: Gaetan Borot (Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin)
    • 9:30 AM 10:20 AM
      A combinatorial approach to random hyperbolic surfaces 50m

      Starting with dynamical triangulations of the string world sheet and matrix models, random maps have occupied a central place in the study of 2d (Euclidean) quantum gravity. Advances in combinatorics (e.g. tree bijections) and probability theory (e.g. Gromov-Hausdorff limits of random metric spaces) led to a rigorous construction of 2d quantum gravity in the form of Brownian geometry on surfaces, and its identification with Liouville Quantum Gravity. In this talk I will describe how some of these methods extend naturally to random hyperbolic geometry on surfaces, a natural alternative to random maps. In particular, I will show how a bijection between the moduli space of genus-0 hyperbolic surfaces (with boundaries) and certain labeled trees provides insight into the associated random metric space.
      Based on joint works with N. Curien and with T. Meeusen and B. Zonneveld.

      Speaker: Timothy Budd (Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands)
    • 10:20 AM 10:50 AM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 10:50 AM 11:40 AM
      Does GCDT solve the Hubble constant tension ? 50m

      CDT might define a quantum theory of gravity, but how one can locate the asymptotic safety UV fixed point is still unclear. However, so-called  generalized CDT models, which allow for baby universe creation, make it possible to conjecture how quantum corrections can influence late time cosmology. The quantum corrections lead to a modified Friedmann equation which does not involve a cosmological constant but nevertheless results in a late time exponential expansion of the universe and in addition solves the Hubble constant tension.

      Speaker: Jan Ambjorn
    • 11:40 AM 12:30 PM
      Graviton, boundaries, BMS symmetry and its cocycles and Beltrami parametrization 50m

      Done in collaboration with Tom Wetzstein

      Speaker: Laurent Baulieu (LPTHE)
    • 12:30 PM 2:30 PM
      Lunch break 2h
    • 2:30 PM 3:20 PM
      Perturbing isoradial triangulations 50m

      Isoradial triangulations are example of critical planar graphs, on which discrete analyticity, integrability, discrete and continuous conformal invariance can be defined and studied for many models. I present some results on the deformations of such triangulations, which break integrability, and their effect on the critical Laplacian and some of its extensions, and for their conformal properties. The relevance and the consequence of these results for some models of two dimensional quantum gravity will be discussed.
      (joint work with J. Scott)

      Speaker: Francois David
    • 3:20 PM 3:50 PM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 3:50 PM 4:20 PM
      Trisections in colored tensor models 30m

      We give a procedure to construct trisections for closed $4$-manifolds generated by colored tensor models without restrictions on the number of simplices in the triangulation, therefore generalizing previous works in the context of crystallizations and PL-manifolds. We give a description of how trisection diagrams can arise from colored tensor model graphs for closed $4$-manifolds.

      Speaker: Reiko Toriumi (OIST)
    • 4:20 PM 4:50 PM
      Generalised spectral dimensions in non-perturbative quantum gravity 30m

      The seemingly universal phenomenon of scale-dependent effective dimensions in non-perturbative theories of quantum gravity has been shown to be a potential source of quantum gravity phenomenology. This scale-dependent effective dimension in quantum gravity has been found by studying the propagation of scalar fields. It is however possible that the non-manifold like structures, that are expected to appear near the Planck scale, have an effective dimension that depends on the type of field under consideration. To investigate this possibility, we have studied the spectral dimension associated to the Laplace-Beltrami operator generalised to k-form fields on spatial slices of the non-perturbative model of quantum gravity known as Causal Dynamical Triangulations. We have found that the two-form, tensor and dual scalar spectral dimensions exhibit a flow between two scales at which an effective dimension appears. However, the one-form and vector spectral dimensions show only a single effective dimension. Albeit speculative for now, the fact that the one-form and vector spectral dimension do not show a flow of the effective dimension in this model can potentially be related to a dynamically generated absence of a dispersion relation for the electromagnetic field, while tensor and scalar fields are affected by dimensional flow.

      Speaker: Marcus Reitz (Jagiellonian University)
    • 9:30 AM 10:20 AM
      Emergence of macroscopic spacetimes in a certain large-N limit of canonical tensor model 50m

      It is challenging to realize emergence of macroscopic spacetimes in tensor models. We study a wave function of a tensor model in the canonical formalism in a certain large-N limit, in which the wave function can reliably be computed classically (namely, by saddle points). We show that spacetimes develop through successive first-order phase transitions, in which numbers of “points” increase one by one. When a positive cosmological constant is turned on, Lie-group symmetric macroscopic spacetimes with locality have large amplitudes.

      Speaker: Naoki Sasakura (Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kyoto University)
    • 10:20 AM 10:50 AM
      Coffee break 30m
    • 10:50 AM 11:40 AM
      Ubiquity of melonic limits in tensor models 50m

      Analogously to matrix models, which provide a combinatorial approach to two-dimensional quantum gravity, tensor models appear to be well-suited to investigations of random geometry in higher dimensions. Indeed, certain generating functions of discrete (pseudo)manifolds, of arbitrary but fixed dimension, can be expressed in terms of (formal) tensor integrals. This being said, obtaining genuinely new universality classes of random geometry from the currently understood scaling limits of tensor models has proven challenging. Among them, the so-called melonic limit is known to produce a branched-polymer phase at criticality, leading to a random geometry of local dimension 4/3 which is unsuitable for quantum gravity. But not all is lost since the combinatorial simplicity of this type of limit has made it a valuable tool to design solvable strongly coupled quantum (field) theories, and via a 2d version of the AdS/CFT correspondence, to investigate quantum gravity itself (albeit from a different perspective). This state of affair raises the question of how ubiquitous melonic limits actually are in tensor models, which will be the focus of this talk. After summarizing the types of tensor representations and invariant interactions that are already known to support melonic limits, I will discuss further conjectures and open problems.

      Speaker: Sylvain Carrozza (Radboud University)
    • 11:40 AM 12:30 PM
      Higher gauge and discrete geometry 50m

      Crossed modules, or (strict) 2-groups, can be used to decorate faces and edges of a 2-complex. In this sense they provide a generalization of lattice gauge theory. I will discuss how these structures are relevant to 4d topological models, possibly to 4d quantum gravity and also provide new mathematical symmetry structures to explore.

      Speaker: Florian Girelli